Choosing Between Redwood & Cedar Fencing
Understanding the difference between redwood and cedar can help you make the right choice for your home’s look, longevity, and budget.
A Natural Choice for Homeowners
When it comes to building a fence that complements your property, redwood and cedar have stood the test of time. Both species offer strength, beauty, and natural resistance to rot — qualities that make them the top picks among Bay Area homeowners. But while they share similarities, subtle differences in tone, texture, and durability can influence your decision.
Appearance and Aesthetic
Redwood is prized for its rich, reddish hue and straight grain. It gives any property a warm, high-end appearance that weathers gracefully to a silver patina if left untreated. Cedar, on the other hand, has a lighter, amber tone that brings an organic, rustic look to outdoor spaces. Its subtle color variations create visual interest, especially when paired with landscaping or garden features.
Durability and Weather Resistance
Redwood’s natural oils provide exceptional defense against decay and insects — a major advantage in the Bay Area’s mixed climate of coastal humidity and inland heat. Cedar is slightly softer but still highly resistant to moisture and pests. With proper maintenance — a quality seal or stain every few years — both can last decades without warping or splitting.
Cost and Value
The biggest difference often comes down to price. Cedar generally costs less than redwood, making it a popular choice for homeowners who want quality without the premium price tag. Redwood’s higher cost reflects its scarcity and visual luxury — but it can also offer longer lifespan and better long-term return on investment.
“We often tell clients that choosing between redwood and cedar isn’t just about cost — it’s about the story you want your property to tell.”
Our Recommendation
For homeowners who want elegance, strength, and minimal upkeep, redwood remains the gold standard. However, cedar is a strong contender when you’re balancing aesthetics with affordability. At H&H Fencing & Decks, we work with both species regularly — always selecting the best grade of lumber for your site conditions and style preferences.